Category: EHN Blog

  • Project NPR-H – The New Packet Radio

    Project NPR-H – The New Packet Radio

    The NPR system would allow a single master station connected to a high-speed backbone, to serve up to seven clients through TDMA and achieve data rates of 65Kb/s on 70cm, economically priced this might be the solution for local clusters to be interconnected.

    The NPR protocol was introduced in 2019 to send data via IPv4 up to 300 kilometers with easy-to-assemble hardware. It was developed by F4HDK and released under a Creative Commons License. The performance of the NPR protocol puts it midway between old packet radio (AX.25) and HSMM-Hamnet with Wifi equipment (AREDN). NPR is capable of usable data rates of between 70 to 500kbps. NPR is a digital protocol using either 2GFSK or 4GFSK (Gaussian frequency shift keying (GFSK). GFSK is a lowpass filtered waveform, so the transmitted RF spectrum falls off quicker at the band edges, it performs worse than FSK but the narrower and better shaped spectrum is specifically tailored to fit well inside UHF band plans.

    Hardware is currently available for 420-450MHz only. It is legal to use in the US, but its capabilities need to be reduced to meet the 100KHz bandwidth license restriction. With the 100KHz restriction the NPR performance is stated as being: Symbol Rate 50kS/s, bandwidth 100kHz, raw data rate 100kb/s raw, usable data rate 65kb/s.

    It gets better, the NPR is designed to operate as simplex channels controlled as a master / slave arrangement, more correctly this is known as Managed TDMA. The master can manage up to 7 clients who can join and leave in an ad-hoc manner. This means a single master that has a connection to a high speed backbone would be able to serve up to seven remote clients vie point to point 70cm links, all with bursts at a data rate of around 65Kb/s, sufficient for the Smart Phone messaging application and typical IoT’s.

    A couple of hardware options are currently available: An advanced version with a power amplifier designed for POE and mounting at the antenna, from Locolino at about $140 each. The original is also available from Elekitsorparts for around $100.

    If a version was available for 33cm (920MHz) it would be able to use the full bandwidth of NPR giving data rates of up 500Kb/s.

  • LoRa – Could this Proprietary Standard Deliver the Bandwidth

    LoRa – Could this Proprietary Standard Deliver the Bandwidth

    LoRa is a system finding some uses in Amateur Radio, but this is limited to operation over poor links and lower bandwidths. It does seem a good fit for point-to-point links on the 920MHz. band where its spread spectrum potential can be used.

    LoRa (from “long range”) is a proprietary low-power wide-area network modulation technique that is popular for connecting the IoT. It is patented and was acquired by Semtech Corporation in 2012. They went on to form the LoRa Alliance who now manage the standard. Primarily designed for use on the unlicensed bands throughout the world, low-cost hardware versions are available for the following bands: 433-435MHz, 863–873 MHz, 915–928 MHz and as a special version for the 2.4GHz band. Extreme noise immunity and long range is achieved using spread spectrum and error correcting coders, low power is achieved by compromising duty cycle and versatility. The output power of the available hardware is between 2-20dBm, throughput between 0.3 kbit/s and 27 kbit/s and range between 3-10 miles.

    Some of the available bands overlap the licensed amateur bands which allow for spread spectrum communications. It is possible to turn off any encryption within LoRa which means the available devices could be used. There are some examples of using LoRa on 70cm for troposcatter and old (2016-2018) examples of making 70cm packet transmissions but little current development. A recent article demonstrating moon-bounce on 70cm was published in Dec 2021 suggesting LoRa is still under active experimentation.

    The available LoRa embedded radio hardware can be configured for different bandwidths and data rates, to meet the 100KHz limit on 70cm the data rate has to be low. Using the LoRa Calculator you can calculate the highest achievable rates. This comes out to a low 4600bps using a bandwidth of 62.5KHz. If we stretch the amateur licensed bandwidth to be 125KHz, then things improve to give a data rate of 9300bps which is still a low data rate. A comparable 2GFSK modulation system is specified at a usable 65000bps while still meeting the CFR 47 Part 97.3 requirements.

    Things could be improved on the 920MHz band where the licensed bandwidth can be much higher. The highest data rate specified for LoRa hardware is with minimal spreading, then at a bandwidth of 500KHz is 37000bps. This is still less than modes like 2GFSK or 4GFSK but LoRa has a much better link bandwidth and so will require much less power and quality of link.

  • Digital Point to Point on the 33cm Amateur Band

    Digital Point to Point on the 33cm Amateur Band

    The 33cm band offers unspecified bandwidth for unspecified digital transmissions using conventional modulation types as well as unspecified Spread Spectrum modulation although limited to 10W pep to the antenna.

    In my reading of Part 97 the 33cm or 900MHz band is the lowest frequency band that does not have a 100KHz transmission bandwidth limitation. It also licenses the Spread Spectrum mode. These facts make it attractive for point-to-point communications requiring higher bandwidths.

    • The specific details are: § 97.301 33cm band.
    • Permitted signals: – MCW, phone, image, RTTY, data, SS, test, pulse
    • Specific limitations:
    • [7] A RTTY, data or multiplexed emission using a specified digital code listed in § 97.309(a) of this part or an unspecified digital code under the limitations listed in § 97.309(b) of this part may be transmitted.
    • [8] A RTTY or data emission having designators with A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, J or R as the first symbol; 1, 2, 7, 9 or X as the second symbol; and D or W as the third symbol is also authorized.
    • [12] Emission F8E may be transmitted.

    None of these limitations apply to Spread Spectrum transmissions which are covered separately as:

    • § 97.311 SS emission types.
    • SS emission transmissions by an amateur station are authorized only for communications between points within areas where the amateur service is regulated by the FCC and between an area where the amateur service is regulated by the FCC and an amateur station in another country that permits such communications. SS emission transmissions must not be used for the purpose of obscuring the meaning of any communication.
    • A station transmitting SS emissions must not cause harmful interference to stations employing other authorized emissions, and must accept all interference caused by stations employing other authorized emissions.
    • When deemed necessary by a Regional Director to assure compliance with this part, a station licensee must:
    • oCease SS emission transmissions.
    • oRestrict SS emission transmissions to the extent instructed; and
    • oMaintain a record, convertible to the original information (voice, text, image, etc.) of all spread spectrum communications transmitted.
    • § 97.313 (j) Transmitter power standards: No station may transmit with a transmitter output exceeding 10 W PEP when the station is transmitting a SS emission type.

    The 33cm band is a shared band and used for portable phones, location services, industrial processes and more. In a point to point environment with good directional antennas reliable communications should be possible.

  • Digital Point to Point on the Lower 1.25M Ham Band

    Digital Point to Point on the Lower 1.25M Ham Band

    Despite the need for approval, the lower part of the 1.25M band could offer interesting possibilities for digital links particularly in urban areas as the frequency has good penetration and coverage although high gain antennas will be physically large.

    Back sometime in the 1990’s the ARRL successfully defended amateurs keeping the lower part of the 1.25M or 220MHz band. The piece between 219-220MHz was designated for secondary use by amateur radio operators. Use is restricted to amateur stations participating as forwarding stations in fixed point-to-point digital message forwarding systems, including intercity packet backbone networks. It is not available for other purposes. This privilege is available to all classes of operator.

    There is a but, as a shared service with amateurs being secondary users’ restrictions apply. For a station within 640km (400miles) of an AMTS coast station you must notify the ARRL 30 days before transmitting so your data can be added to a public database. If you are withing 80km (50miles) of such a coast station you will need written permission to operate, again obtained by asking the ARRL.

    The Automated Maritime Telecommunications System (AMTS) is a commercial mobile radio service used within the United States. It offers both voice and data communications to maritime customers. The system is operated by a network of private carriers across the country, with coverage primarily including coastal and inland waterways. I was unable to find any public database or maps of AMTS locations.

    Given most operators would be within 400miles of some negatable waterway, use of this part of the spectrum probably requires authorization but since this is for fixed point to point links negotiating a usable link budget should be possible for many. This opens a dedicated piece of spectrum for point-to-point use that does not seem to be heavily used.

    Let’s now look at the permitted modes and bandwidth limitations.

    • § 97.307 Emission standards section 13 – A data emission using an unspecified digital code under the limitations listed in § 97.309(b) also may be transmitted. The authorized bandwidth is 100 kHz.

    This seems to suggest any form of digital code, presumably provided it is openly published and available to all, with a bandwidth of 100KHz, a respectable amount capable of supporting a moderate speed link. This bandwidth is much more than the 20Khz permitted on the 2M band and lacks any RTTY and emission limitations of the higher portion of the 1.25M band or 70cm band.

  • Emergency Ham Network – Is it Legal?

    Emergency Ham Network – Is it Legal?

    I have been doing my due diligence on the legality of operating the imagined Emergency Ham Network (EHN). The short answer is yes if there is an emergency and probably if there is not.

    Since all licensed radio operators have passed examinations, we all know we are governed by part 97 of the relevant FCC regulations. This document clearly sets out what we can and cannot do as licensed operators. It is dangerous to just pick out and quote specific sub-sections or regulations because it is important to understand the context by reading the whole document with any supporting documents. However, since we all don’t have time and much of it will not be critical to the operation of the EHN I have drawn up a brief summery of what I believe to be the relevant issues.

    First I cannot stop myself reminding everybody of the basic purpose allowing the existence of Ham Radio.

    Section 97.1 subsections 1-5:

    • Recognition and enhancement of the value of the amateur service to the public as a voluntary noncommercial communication service, particularly with respect to providing emergency communications.
    • Continuation and extension of the amateur’s proven ability to contribute to the advancement of the radio art.
    • Encouragement and improvement of the amateur service through rules which provide for advancing skills in both the communication and technical phases of the art.
    • Expansion of the existing reservoir within the amateur radio service of trained operators, technicians, and electronics experts.
    • Continuation and extension of the amateur’s unique ability to enhance international goodwill.

    Emergency communications is the first item, that use is further clarified in section 97.403 – Safety of life and protection of property.

    • No provision of these rules prevents the use by an amateur station of any means of radiocommunication at its disposal to provide essential communication needs in connection with the immediate safety of human life and immediate protection of property when normal communication systems are not available.

    The remaining subsections of our purpose are not called out specifically but are the reason we have the use of the spectrum and communication modes.

    When it comes to quantifying a modern digital network withing section 97 I believe there is a need for a little imagination and analysis of current operating practices. I think this is because the term digital or digital station does not appear in the formal definitions section (section 97.3) but it does define the term digital code as a type of modulation.

    Is there any mention of a digital station in part 97?

    Yes, confusingly the term digital station occurs just once in section 97.221 – Automatically Controlled Digital Station. This section discusses limitations for specific frequencies but delivers a hard blow in sub-section C part 2 which states:

    • No transmission from the automatically controlled station occupies a bandwidth of more than 500 Hz.

    A bandwidth of 500Hz makes sense on the HF bands which is where the term digital code seems most at home. Since I cannot find what is meant by a “digital station” I am worried that it could be applied to aspects of the EHN. The currently operating AREDN Mesh Network clearly uses more than 500Hz and appears to be an automatically controlled station. Section 97.221 also makes it clear it does not apply to an auxiliary station, a beacon station, a repeater station, an earth station, a space station, or a space telecommand station. Note they list auxiliary station and repeater station separately suggesting they are different.

    Two more terms that could be used to describe the EHN come up, the first is

    • Auxiliary Station – An amateur station, other than in a message forwarding system, that is transmitting communications point-to-point within a system of cooperating amateur stations.

    This sounds a bit like a network, although I suspect it is really referring to stations passing messages or repeaters. This fact is further qualified by the ARRL in their Auxiliary Station FAQ but they only use voice as an example with one reference to using DTMF tones for control. The use case examples do not have references and so I could not validate their context and they do not consider repeaters as a separate item to auxiliary stations. It is quite possible that this section could indeed cover a system of cooperating digital nodes communicating through a digital link.

    The second term is

    • Message forwarding system. – A group of amateur stations participating in a voluntary, cooperative, interactive arrangement where communications are sent from the control operator of an originating station to the control operator of one or more destination stations by one or more forwarding stations.

    I cannot find any explanation as to what defines communications or interactive arrangement, but it would seem that digital packets and computer control could well qualify provided we meet the control operator requirements.

    In conclusion, in an emergency radio operators can take extraordinary measures to help save lives or property but keeping in mind we would need to justify those measures after the fact and may be held accountable if we were reckless.

    In normal times if we quietly ignore section 97.221, we can operate either as an auxiliary station or part of a message forwarding system depending on if our data is for control or of substance.

    My next blog will look at the license rules for the different bands, modulation type, power and types of messages.

  • The Younger Generation – Ham Radios Future?

    The Younger Generation – Ham Radios Future?

    As an atypical white male in my 60’s I struggle to remain connected with young people, I read about Millennials and what our experts predict will result from the changes in society. The best I can conclude comes in the form of the following two quotes from an excellent 2012 study:

    Main findings: Teens, technology, and human potential in 2020 – Pew Research Center

    This is a satisfying read, a good way of quickly getting inside this generations psyche but it also contains a diverse selection of predictions from many onlookers. So, conclusions are difficult to identify but some things stuck in my mind when considering how to encourage Ham Radio survive.

    • Students don’t read books. They rarely read long articles. When they do read, they don’t read for arguments. Instead, they skim the middles of pages, perhaps moving their eyes up and down if something interests them. They don’t work on retaining what little they read, or even seem to think that taking notes is necessary. Their reasons seem to be that they can always find out whenever they need to. The future will belong to those who can focus. This will be an increasingly small and rare group of people.
    • David D. Burstein, a student at New York University and author of Fast Future: How the Millennial Generation is Remaking Our World, noted, “A focus on nostalgia for print materials, penmanship, and analog clock reading skills will disappear as Millennials and the generation that follows us will redefine valued skills, which will likely include internet literacy, how to mine information, how to read online, etc.”

    My Experience

    I have been a mentor to several and helped them be successful. I measure success by them surviving (lost one to drug overdose) and being independent of their parents with sufficient extra resources to pass on the gift of mentorship. My advice has changed over the years, I am no longer suggesting Universities but today I say learn a skill or craft, better still learn a few. Out of all those I have been fortunate enough to witness and influence part of their lives, I have seen Doctors, Local Government, Teachers but the most successful is an Electrician who has built a small business that is thriving enabling them to live what I thought was the American dream. It’s been ten years or so since I was able to connect and influence a young person. For me it is difficult to find a safe situation to communicate and so I now sit on the sidelines watching and looking for a new opportunity to give back.

  • What is an Emergency Ham Network Smart Phone System?

    What is an Emergency Ham Network Smart Phone System?

      Overview

    This document describes a possible peripheral for the imagined Emergency Ham Network. This could be the killer application for the network or just some ideas that is looking to find a problem. Only by writing this paper can that question be asked.

    Why might we want to do this? What problem are we trying to solve?

    • How to communicate to and from the general public in a severe emergency that has taken down the cell phone and internet.

    What are the consequences of not solving this?

    • Overloading and panic at staffed official offices, people moving on mass to find information when it might be better to have stayed at their home / business. Missing important public safety messages.

    What might the advantages be?

    • Lowering the tension and anxiety of the general public during an emergency that has taken down the Cell Phone and local internet by providing a pocket of cell phone text messaging.
    • Providing a way nonemergency messages such as who is safe and wanting to let loved ones know, through to potentially lifesaving requests for medicine or help.

    What is the opportunity?

    • It is assumed that the Emergency Services and Local Government will have their own Emergency Communications but limited chance to use them for more general and personal messages.
    • No clear plans appear to be in place for getting messages from the general public during an emergency that takes out the cell and internet systems.
    • Emergency Alert radio (EAS) will send general messages but requires a radio receiver or phone system. In an emergency, radios and such are no longer widely available.
    • Recent changes in climate and disease have heightened the need to more resilient emergency systems. This proposal has the potential to deliver a scalable system quickly.
    • Every local official office could potentially want one of these systems to manage and communicate with its local population. Even without the Amateur Radio interconnections, a local township might want to consider linking their various buildings to form a viable emergency network.

    System Assumptions

    1. The aim of this system is to provide an off-grid method of sending and receiving simple text messaging capabilities with a smart phone equipped with a suitable application. Except for the Emergency 911 type service, all messages would use the calling and caller cell phone numbers for identification and routing.Messages would be passed to and from the smart phone using conventional Wi-Fi signals and some form of standard packet transport service.
    2. A small local area would be covered by multiple high power Wi-Fi Hot Spots all linked by ethernet to a local server which would provide the application interface, web server for downloading the application and a public website for displaying important information. In a formally declared Emergency these messages would include those sent to the current emergency response network as well as any other messages authorized by the local emergency center. Undeliverable received messages would be displayed on this public website and also be passed the local command center and/ or the local PBS network. This will provide an electronic public message board so people can find each other and get notified who is safe.
    3. It must be made clear to users that this system is not private, other than in test mode, the system is likely to share users with authorities and make public any messages that are not delivered.
    4. This local server and Hot Spots would be capable of operating in isolation, creating an island of connectivity covering the extent of the Wi-Fi range. In a quiet environment perhaps 1000-foot circle could be expected, perhaps more if the terrain permits. This distance could well increase as technology and experimentation provides measured results.
    5. Local servers can be connected to other local servers and to a central server backbone using a mix of VHF/UHF point to point links or a link to a microwave backbone. Mobile local servers could be set up in public places such as municipal building or hospitals. This system is suited to places where there are a lot of people looking for help or information.
    6. This system will use encrypted transmissions for the Wi-Fi connection to the local server. This transmission will include encrypted identifiers to validate the pairing of application to server. This is permissible under Part 15 of the FCC code. No license is needed to send messages from to and from the phone.
    7. Initial deployments would only deliver messages to numbers that had enrolled on the system. These messages would be delivered through the standard carrier SMS service.If an outbound number is already registered on the system, it will be delivered internally without going to the SMS network. This means there should be a local server dB of registered numbers and a central roll up of all local servers. This implies a central db.
    8. All messages should be logged to the local server and also at the central server. Priority should be given to sending messages between servers over collecting log files.
    9. In an emergency, messages to non-registered users would be displayed on the server’s website for anybody to see using a connected Wi-Fi equipped browser without any password login. This is so that website would become a public message board in the affected area.
    10. As part of registration the phone will receive any important messages and display them to the user.
    11. A general broadcast message to all registered phones should be supported so an important message can be broadcast quickly and effectively. Messages can be sent from the local operator or come through the link to the central server.
    12. The phone application will also make the phone act like a beacon if no local server can be found. This will help Emergency Services find the phone and its owners through finding and tracking the Wi-Fi signal.

      What do you all think? Add your comment below.

  • Making the Emergency Ham Network FUN!

    Making the Emergency Ham Network FUN!

    stazione-meteo-bit-line.jpg

    We talked about the value in using the EHN 24/7 even without an emergency, primarily because of the “use it or loose it” theory on our licensed spectrum. But what would we use for traffic, how can we give some reward to all our contributors who would have spent their time and effort building out the network? Bluntly, what gratification and enjoyment can we all get once its built. How can we make it fun?

    Well, the Internet of Things seems to generate a whole lot of interest and value in many of our day to day lives. I’m not so much thinking of using the EHN to switch on lights or the TV but monitoring and sending all the data from a connected weather station, perhaps the power voltage/frequency. Even the current speed of your internet connection. With this data sent daily from every node and posted on a map of the US we would have an interesting display of the net’s capability. I am sure more mutually helpful tings to monitor would mature as we all share our experience and expectation.

    Although not a IoT, if many of the EHN nodes could interface a radio to regularly measure beacons across the bands, we would get a real time map of propagation within the US and beyond. Now that feels more like a useful contribution to our cause.

    So, I believe a digital Emergency Ham Network, connecting hundreds of nodes across America would open up beneficial and fun service everybody could enjoy and learn.

    What would you like to see connected? Share your thoughts. Comment below.

  • Autopatch or Phonepatch Matures into the Biggest EHN Customer Base?

    Autopatch or Phonepatch Matures into the Biggest EHN Customer Base?

    pexels-maarten-van-den-heuvel-4254896.jpg

    Back in the day, more precisely the 1960’s Amateur Radio Operators provided a valuable service during the Vietnam war. By coupling the local phone system to their transceivers Hams were able to allow American soldiers “free” phone calls home. Usually, you needed the help of an operator in your own state as interstate trunk calls were expensive, but since local calls were typically free, this service flourished. It was not only during times of war that this service was used or permitted. It was common right up to the time when the POTS changed and free state calling became the norm.
    The Amateur license permits third parties to talk, today this is often used to let people talk over the radio at events or for friends. But that privilege extends to those connected to the telephone network. Our license also permits autonomous operation for digital and RTTY transmissions.

    Does this mean that we would be able to connect a cell phone and link them for third party communications, a step further, could we link cell phones and let text messages pass to and from an Emergency Ham network? If so, we have a potentially huge customer base in an emergency. We might assume that the Emergency Services are well cared for in a disaster, but the general population? Who will pass messages from loved ones, those in need of medical supplies or just find out who is safe? Radio Operators that have the means to pass text messages direct from peoples cell phones using an approved app (voice may require too much bandwidth) would surely become invaluable and provide a service that I do not believe can be met any other way.

    Do you believe we could ever pass such traffic? Share your Ideas and comments below.

  • The ARRL National Traffic System (NTS) is not like the proposed Emergency Ham Network.

    The ARRL National Traffic System (NTS) is not like the proposed Emergency Ham Network.

    pexels-rodnae-productions-7841837.jpg

    For generations the ARRL has overseen NTS. This national system says in Its documentation “to handle written traffic and participate in directed nets.” Reading more of the official documentation, it was difficult for me to get a clear understanding of their charter or administration process. There is a well-developed operating procedures and rules. Digging further I find this extract from the ARRL main documentation “Frequently, ARRL Headquarters is asked how a net or digital node (BBS) may become a part of NTS. This usually isn’t easy, because NTS is not a “club for nets” which any existing net may join at will. In addition, making nets a part of NTS is less a matter of official action than a “state of mind” of the net itself.” It goes on and in subsequent points appear to make it clear that any net within NTS can only operate within region and not beyond those boundaries.

    My reading of this and unanswered questions from ARIS officials leads me to conclude that if there was a valid Emergency Ham Network that offered advantages to NETS, they may include it as required. But they had no mandate or desire to help create such a network.

    Therefor I think it is reasonable to conclude that the independent formation of a group of Licensed Radio Operators, like an Emergency Ham Network, will not compete with any current ARRL groups.

    What is your experience or views? Comment below.